• Home
  • Anti-Corruption
  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
  • National
    • Government
  • Security
  • Features
  • State
  • Event
    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Search
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
PRNIGERIA PRNigeria News
PRNIGERIA PRNIGERIA
  • Home
  • Anti-Corruption
    • ICPC Secures Conviction of Rector for Running Unaccredited Degree Programmes

      Engr Abba Babagana Dalori

      Engr Dalori Forfeits Galaxy Hospital, Petrol Station, Properties & Cash

      Chinese nationals jailed in Lagos

      Court Jails Nine Chinese Nationals for Cybercrime in Lagos

      ASUU

      Tackle Corruption, Institutional Decay – ASUU Charges FG

      EFCC Arraigns Bauchi Accountant General Over N8bn Fraud as Court Sentences…

  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
    • PRNigeria Fellows and CEO IMPR Yushau A Shuaib

      PRNigeria Fellowship: A Model for NIPSS Kuru

      Africa’s Economic Ties Deepen as Nigeria, Benin Sign Joint Trade Plan

      Customs Partners US Mission to Prevent Expanded Visa Ban

      Nigeria Customs Partners China on Smarter Ports, Officer Training, Reforms

      Comptroller General Nigerian Customs Bashir Adewale

      Customs Moves Against 223 Importers in N379bn Permit Breach

  • National
    • Pantami Urges Presidential Rewards for Nigerian Teen, Nafisa Aminu Who Topped…

      Customs Unveils Reputation Handbook to Guide Officers’ Conduct, Rebrand Agency

      CDCFIB

      Correctional Service Elevates 30 Officers to Assistant Controller General Rank

      Troops Intercept Illicit Logistics Bound for Cameroon, Uncovers, Destroys 14 IEDs…

      Group photograph of Staffs of VON and representatives from RATTAWU

      We are Here to Fix The Voice of Nigeria as A…

    • Government
      • Pantami Urges Presidential Rewards for Nigerian Teen, Nafisa Aminu Who Topped…

        Secretary State Government Alhaji Umar Farouk Ibrahim receives report on Commissioner alleged role in drug baron bail

        Kano Govt Receives Report on Commissioner’s Alleged Role in Drug Baron’s…

        Group photograph of Staffs of VON and representatives from RATTAWU

        We are Here to Fix The Voice of Nigeria as A…

        The Executive Secretary of the National Sugar Development Council (NSDC), Mr. Kamar Bakrin (L), receiving the President of the All Farmers’ Association of Nigeria (AFAN), Dr Farouk Rabiu Mudi (R), who led a delegation to pay him a courtesy visit in his office.

        Why Investments in Local Sugar Production is Profitable Now – NSDC…

        Kemi Badenoch

        Kemi Oomoale Badenough: A Liar By no Other Name by Chief…

  • Security
    • Nigerian Army Launches New Welfare Initiatives for Retiring Soldiers

      CDCFIB

      Correctional Service Elevates 30 Officers to Assistant Controller General Rank

      PRNigeria logo fearured image

      After 21 Years, Gen. TY Danjuma Relaunches Union Dicon Salt to…

      Rivers Police Arrest Suspects in Lawyer’s Murder, Recover Weapons

      Police Officer

      Police Eliminate 8 Terrorists in Zamfara as Bandits Abduct 5 Residents,…

  • Features
    • Tinubu, Atiku and Peter Obi

      Atiku, Obi and the ‘Confused Marriage’ Called ADC

      Kwankwaso, Northern Nigeria and the Politics of Marginalisation

      Kemi Badenoch

      Kemi Oomoale Badenough: A Liar By no Other Name by Chief…

      DSS, NNPCL and EFCC

      NNPCL Controversy: Arewa Economic Forum Raises Alarm as EFCC, DSS Refute…

      Tinubu’s Greek gift by Festus Adedayo

  • State
    • Secretary State Government Alhaji Umar Farouk Ibrahim receives report on Commissioner alleged role in drug baron bail

      Kano Govt Receives Report on Commissioner’s Alleged Role in Drug Baron’s…

      Rivers Police Arrest Suspects in Lawyer’s Murder, Recover Weapons

      Police Officer

      Police Eliminate 8 Terrorists in Zamfara as Bandits Abduct 5 Residents,…

      Troops Intercept Illicit Logistics Bound for Cameroon, Uncovers, Destroys 14 IEDs…

      Prof Pate donates laptops to UNIMAID

      Prof Pate donates 20 Laptop Computers to UNIMAID

  • Event
    • Pantami Urges Presidential Rewards for Nigerian Teen, Nafisa Aminu Who Topped…

      NIPR President Ike Neliaku and Customs Boss Bashir Adewale Adeniyi

      NIPR Lauds Customs’ Reputation Reforms, Announces Annual PR Officer Award

      Prof Pate donates laptops to UNIMAID

      Prof Pate donates 20 Laptop Computers to UNIMAID

      D'Tigress Basketball team

      Will Presidential Gifts Follow as Nigerian Female Basketballers D’Tigress Reach 5th…

      The Paramount Ruler of Oka-Akoko, His Imperial Majesty Oba (Dr) Yusuf Adebori Adeleye, OON, the Olubaka of Oka

      Olubaka of Oka Praises Foundation for “Best Oka Day” Festival

    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Home Security Court Awards N5.5b damages against Nigerian Customs over unlawful seizure of rice...
  • Security

Court Awards N5.5b damages against Nigerian Customs over unlawful seizure of rice consignment

By
Prnigeria
-
July 10, 2019
NCS customs operations lagos
NCS customs operations lagos

Court Awards N5.5b damages against Nigerian Customs over unlawful seizure of rice consignment

A Federal High Court in Abuja has awarded damages amounting to over N5.5billion against the Nigerian Customs Service (NCS) and the Chairman, Nigerian Customs Service Board (NCSB) over their unlawful seizure of 90 containers of rice imported by a firm, Maggpiy Trading TFZE.

Maggpiy stated in its suit, marked:FHC/CA/CS/40/2017 that, on March 18, 2017, officials of the NCS invaded and sealed up its warehouse in the Tinapa Free Trade Zone (TFTZ), Calabar, containing over 90containers of rice stored in air-tight containers.

The plaintiff said, in addition to sealing its warehouse with its content, officials of the NCS stole part of the seized rice and detained its 40 trucks, containing 317 transit containers of rice, destined for the Tinapa Free Trade Zone, without lawful justification for 120 days along Onne, Port-Harcourt road.

In a judgment on Wednesday, Justice Inyang Ekwo upheld the plaintiff’s claims and held that the 1stand 2nd respondents – NCS and the Chairman, NCSB – acted unlawfully and without any justification in law.

Justice Ekwo rejected the defence raised by the NCS and the Chairman, NCSB and their attempt to justify their actions.

The judge faulted the 1st and 2nd defendants’ claim that they acted under the Federal Ministry of Finance Import Guidelines, Procedures and Documentation Requirements under the Destination Inspection Scheme in Nigeria.

Justice Ekwo held that, not only was the document inadmissible and worthless, having not been signed; there was no provision in the document that made it applicable to Free Trade Zones.

“I have studied the document, I cannot find anywhere it is made applicable to Free Trade Zones, which both parties have agreed, is a country within a country.”

The judge also rejected some circular tendered by the Customs to justify their action.

Justice Ekwo held that not only were most of the circulars made after the plaintiff’s rice consignment was seized on March 18, 2017, the defendants failed to show the law and orders pursuant to which the circulars were issued.

“The circular made on March 30, 2017, declaring Free Trade Zones, as land borders cannot apply to this case because it does, not have a retrospective effect.

“Therefore, the circulars, made after the plaintiff had imported the rice, and relied upon by the 1st and 2nd defendants, do not apply to this case,” the judge said.

Justice Ekwo also faulted the 1st and 2nd defendant’s argument that they were exempted, under the Customs and Excise Management Act, the from any liability and prosecution while applying the provisions of the law.

The judge said such exemption only applies where officials of the NCS are exercising the power granted by the law – the Customs and Excise Management Act.

Read Also:

  • Pantami Urges Presidential Rewards for Nigerian Teen, Nafisa Aminu Who Topped Global English Competition
  • NIPR Lauds Customs’ Reputation Reforms, Announces Annual PR Officer Award
  • Customs Unveils Reputation Handbook to Guide Officers’ Conduct, Rebrand Agency

He added: “It has not been shown to this court the provisions of the said Act that authorises any of the Customs officials to enter and seal a business premises in a Free Trade Zone
“In that case, the foray of the 1st and 2nd defendants into the territory of the Tinapa Free Trade Zone and Resort, which is not a territory of the 1st and 2nd defendants, and which was not to enforce the provisions of the Nigerian Export Processing Zone Act or any regulation there of,was illegal and unlawful.

“The argument by the 1st and 2nd defendants that the plaintiff was importing its rice through the land border was questionable, because the containers they seized were merely being transported on land, from Onne Sea Port to the Tinapa Free Trade Zoneand Resort.

“The containers were therefore, in transit between one sea port and another. And, being in transit cannot be interpreted as land border importation.”
The judge described as infantile the argument that the plaintiff, in importing rice, acted outside its operating licence which was for the plaintiff to trade in food and beverages in Tinapa Free Trade Zone.

Justice Ekwo noted that such an argument amounted to a futile attempt to distinguish between rice and food.
The judge frowned at the discovery that part of the seized consignment was stolen by officials of the Nigerian Customs, while the plaintiff’s warehouse was sealed by the 1sstand 2nd defendants.

He said: “another intriguing part of the defendants action, during the course of this proceedings, is the discovery that, when stocks were taken, upon the unsealing of the warehouse by the 1st and 2nd defendants, 19421 of 50 kg bags and 1639 of 25 kg of the seized rice consignment have been pilfered by officers of the 1st and 2nd defendants.
“The 1st and 2nd defendants proferred no defence on this issue nor countered the evidence of the plaintiff.

“This, in my opinion, is a brazen act of treating the proceedings before the court with contempt apart from the reprehensible theft that the act of the 1st and 2nd defendants represents.”
The judge further held that the1st and 2nd defendants failed to supply evidence in support of their allegation that the plaintiff was involved in the smuggling of rice.

He added that smuggling being a criminal offence, the1st and 2nd defendant ought to provide evidence of prosecution or conviction of the plaintiff for the alleged offence of smuggling.
Justice Ekwo also frowned at the 1stand 2nd defendants’ failure to obey two different interlocutory orders of the court,which were intended to mitigate the loss which the plaintiff eventually suffered as a result of the theft of part of the seized goods and contermination from prolong sealing of the warehouse.
The judge granted all the reliefs by the plaintiff and awarded specific and general in damages in favour of the plaintiff, and against the 1st and 2nd defendants, in the amount estimated at N3,805,638,950 and $4,796,550.

Justice Ekwo also granted an order of perpetual injunction restraining the defendants from further unlawfully interfering with the lawful business transactions of the plaintiff within the Tinapa Free Trade Zone.

He also said the judgements um shall attract interest “at the prevailing Monetary Policy Rate of the Central Bank from the date of judgment until judgment sum is fully paid.”

Although the National Security Adviser (NSA) was sued as the 3rd defendant, Justice Ekwo said the plaintiff made out no case against the 3rd defendant.‎

By PRNigeria

VISIT OUR OTHER WEBSITES
PRNigeria.com EconomicConfidential.com PRNigeria.com/Hausa/
EmergencyDigest.com PoliticsDigest.ng TechDigest.ng
HealthDigest.ng SpokesPersonsdigest.com TeensDigest.ng
ArewaAgenda.com Hausa.ArewaAgenda.com YAShuaib.com
  • TAGS
  • Court
  • NCS
  • NCSB
Previous articlePresident Buhari Seeks Approval of 15 Special Advisers
Next articleJohn Abang Resumes as Anambra Police Commissioner
Prnigeria
Prnigeria
http://www.PRNigeria.com

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Nigerian Army Launches New Welfare Initiatives for Retiring Soldiers

CDCFIB

Correctional Service Elevates 30 Officers to Assistant Controller General Rank

PRNigeria logo fearured image

After 21 Years, Gen. TY Danjuma Relaunches Union Dicon Salt to Revive Local Industry

Rivers Police Arrest Suspects in Lawyer’s Murder, Recover Weapons

Police Officer

Police Eliminate 8 Terrorists in Zamfara as Bandits Abduct 5 Residents, Rustle Cattle

Troops Intercept Illicit Logistics Bound for Cameroon, Uncovers, Destroys 14 IEDs in Borno

PRNigeria Fellows and CEO IMPR Yushau A Shuaib

PRNigeria Fellowship: A Model for NIPSS Kuru

Nigerian Police Force

PSC Denies Police Recruitment, Warns Against Fraudulent Online Claims

Military Troops in Action

Troops Raid Bandits Camps, Eliminate 1, Recover Motorcycles

Troops Kill 3 Terrorists in Borno, Recover Weapons, Motorcycles

NDLEA Logo

NDLEA Intercepts Cocaine, Tramadol Hidden in Vehicle Side Mirrors, Arrests Multiple Suspects Nationwide

ICPC Boss, Musa Adamu and CG Customs, Bashir Adeniyi during his courtesy visit to ICPC office in Abuja

Customs, ICPC Partner to Curb Smuggling, Boost Revenue Through Transparent Enforcement

LEAVE A REPLY Cancel reply

Log in to leave a comment

Recent Posts

  • Pantami Urges Presidential Rewards for Nigerian Teen, Nafisa Aminu Who Topped Global English Competition
  • NIPR Lauds Customs’ Reputation Reforms, Announces Annual PR Officer Award
  • Customs Unveils Reputation Handbook to Guide Officers’ Conduct, Rebrand Agency
  • Atiku, Obi and the ‘Confused Marriage’ Called ADC
  • Nigerian Army Launches New Welfare Initiatives for Retiring Soldiers
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
© 2020 PRNigeria. All Rights Reserved.
Latest News
Pantami Urges Presidential Rewards for Nigerian Teen, Nafisa Aminu Who Topped Global English CompetitionNIPR Lauds Customs’ Reputation Reforms, Announces Annual PR Officer AwardCustoms Unveils Reputation Handbook to Guide Officers’ Conduct, Rebrand AgencyAtiku, Obi and the ‘Confused Marriage’ Called ADCNigerian Army Launches New Welfare Initiatives for Retiring SoldiersCorrectional Service Elevates 30 Officers to Assistant Controller General RankAfter 21 Years, Gen. TY Danjuma Relaunches Union Dicon Salt to Revive Local IndustryKano Govt Receives Report on Commissioner's Alleged Role in Drug Baron's BailRivers Police Arrest Suspects in Lawyer's Murder, Recover WeaponsPolice Eliminate 8 Terrorists in Zamfara as Bandits Abduct 5 Residents, Rustle CattleTroops Intercept Illicit Logistics Bound for Cameroon, Uncovers, Destroys 14 IEDs in BornoWe are Here to Fix The Voice of Nigeria as A True Instrument of National Power – DG VONWhy Investments in Local Sugar Production is Profitable Now - NSDC BossKwankwaso, Northern Nigeria and the Politics of MarginalisationKemi Oomoale Badenough: A Liar By no Other Name by Chief Femi Fani-Kayode
X whatsapp