• Home
  • Anti-Corruption
  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
  • National
    • Government
  • Security
  • Features
  • State
  • Event
    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Search
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
PRNIGERIA PRNigeria News
PRNIGERIA PRNIGERIA
  • Home
  • Anti-Corruption
    • ICPC Secures Conviction of Rector for Running Unaccredited Degree Programmes

      Engr Abba Babagana Dalori

      Engr Dalori Forfeits Galaxy Hospital, Petrol Station, Properties & Cash

      Chinese nationals jailed in Lagos

      Court Jails Nine Chinese Nationals for Cybercrime in Lagos

      ASUU

      Tackle Corruption, Institutional Decay – ASUU Charges FG

      EFCC Arraigns Bauchi Accountant General Over N8bn Fraud as Court Sentences…

  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
    • Customs Partners US Mission to Prevent Expanded Visa Ban

      Nigeria Customs Partners China on Smarter Ports, Officer Training, Reforms

      Comptroller General Nigerian Customs Bashir Adewale

      Customs Moves Against 223 Importers in N379bn Permit Breach

      Bashir Adewale Adeniyi Customs Boss

      How Customs is Tightening Borders to Stop Illicit Cash Flows –…

      Customs boss, CGC Bashir Adewale Adeniyi with NAFDAC DG Professor Moji Adeyeye

      Codeine, Tramadol Worth ₦20.5bn Seized as Customs-NAFDAC Cooperation Deepens

  • National
    • Beyond Hoes and Sticks: The Power of Education for Peace in…

      Nigerian Air Force Welcomes 30 New Helicopter Pilots, Commissions Upgraded Facilities

      National Blood Service Agency

      FG Pledges Stronger Support for Blood Services, Seeks Scalable Interventions from…

      Tinubu’s Government Unveils Multi-Sectoral Initiatives to Boost Northern Region’s Development

      DCG Olumode Samuel Adeyemi

      JUST IN: Tinubu Appoints Olumode Adeyemi New CG of Fire Service

    • Government
      • Beyond Hoes and Sticks: The Power of Education for Peace in…

        National Blood Service Agency

        FG Pledges Stronger Support for Blood Services, Seeks Scalable Interventions from…

        Tinubu’s Government Unveils Multi-Sectoral Initiatives to Boost Northern Region’s Development

        Minister of State for Agriculture, Dr Aliyu S. Abdullahi,

        FG Redesigns Agricultural Curriculum to Empower Youth

        Prof. Attahiru Jega, Co-Chairman of the Presidential Committee on Livestock Reforms,

        FG Unveils Livestock Blueprint to End Herdsmen-Farmers Crisis

  • Security
    • Nigerian Air Force Welcomes 30 New Helicopter Pilots, Commissions Upgraded Facilities

      DCG Olumode Samuel Adeyemi

      JUST IN: Tinubu Appoints Olumode Adeyemi New CG of Fire Service

      Troops Neutralise 6 Terrorists in Coordinated Operations Across Borno, Recover Firearms

      Police Officer

      Police Nab Woman Linked to Murder of Pregnant Nurse, Mutilation in…

      Coordinated Security Efforts Making Nigeria Safer Under Tinubu’s Administration – NSA…

  • Features
    • Okello Oculi

      Okello Oculi: A Pan-Africanist Asteroid Burns out Forever By Is’haq Modibbo…

      Leon Usigbe

      Death, you can’t be Proud of this By Abdulrahman Abdulraheem 

      Tinubu’s Plateau Gambit – Yilwatda, 2027, and the Return of the…

      Ozumi and a recipient of a wheelchair

      Wheels of Hope: How a Simple Gift is Reshaping Lives at…

      Late Ex-President Muhammadu Buhari and Mansur Liman

      “Buhari: A Blunt, Honest Leader Who Laughed at His Own Predicament”

  • State
    • Beyond Hoes and Sticks: The Power of Education for Peace in…

      National Blood Service Agency

      FG Pledges Stronger Support for Blood Services, Seeks Scalable Interventions from…

      Tinubu’s Government Unveils Multi-Sectoral Initiatives to Boost Northern Region’s Development

      Troops Neutralise 6 Terrorists in Coordinated Operations Across Borno, Recover Firearms

      nipr logo

      NIPR Slams Fake News Peddlers over Alleged Lafia Flyover Collapse

  • Event
    • Founder Image Merchant Promotion Ltd, Yushau Shuaib, Nigeria Customs CG, CGC Bashir Adewale Adeniyi and the IPRA representative during the 2024 GWA awards in Belgrade, Serbia

      IPRA Celebrates 70th Anniversary, Hosts 2025 Golden World Awards in Ghana

      IMPR Interns

      Unpacking Dr. Fatima Binta’s NIPR Vision: A Candid Chat with PRNigeria…

      Dr. Ahmadu Fatimah Binta

      Beyond the Clinic: Dr. Fatimah Binta Reveals PR’s Impact on Medicine

      FGC Yauri schoolgirls

      Kidnapped FGC Yauri Schoolgirls Defy Odds, Graduate with Distinction from Top…

      Super Falcons wins WAFCON Trophy

      VON Apologizes for Erroneous WAFCON Report, Cites Possible Security Breach, Identifies…

    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Home Features I would criticize the supreme court- An open letter to the Chief...
  • Features

I would criticize the supreme court- An open letter to the Chief Justice of Nigeria 

By
Richard Akinlola
-
February 13, 2023
Olukayode Ariwoola
Olukayode Ariwoola

I would criticize the supreme court- An open letter to the Chief Justice of Nigeria

My Lord the Chief Justice,

I read with utter consternation, your press statement issued on your behalf by your Director of Press and Information, Festus Akande, wherein you took the unprecedented step to gag the public in criticizing the apex court.
I must hasten to say from the onset that the Supreme Court is one of the institutions of democracy, hence it’s judgments are subject to public scrutiny. What l don’t subscribe to are personal, scurrilous attacks of justices but with the greatest respect my Lord, your judgments are subject to public scrutiny, particularly when they impart on public policy or political processes. Perhaps, my Lord is oblivious of the perception out there in the public domain, that the Supreme Court in the past couple years has been compromised, compared to the Supreme Court of yore during the time of Kayode Eso, Otutu Obaseki, Adolphus Karibi-Whyte, Chukwudifu Oputa et al. This may not be so but perception is often more stronger than the reality.

In the past 40 years, l have written on the judiciary, right from the time Chief Justices Atanda Fatai-Williams, George Sowemimo, Ayo Irikefe, till date and l haven’t seen a situation where the Supreme Court would attempt to gag members of the public, legal practitioners inclusive, from criticizing the judgments or even conducts of judicial officers. Apart from being an infringement on section 39 of the 1999 constitution (as amended), it portends grave danger to the administration of justice.

Read Also:

  • Beyond Hoes and Sticks: The Power of Education for Peace in Arewa
  • Nigerian Air Force Welcomes 30 New Helicopter Pilots, Commissions Upgraded Facilities
  • FG Pledges Stronger Support for Blood Services, Seeks Scalable Interventions from NBSA

I have, in the past risen to defend the judgments of the Supreme Court, not just as articles but in book form. See “The Sokoto Election Debacle and the Supreme Court” (2012) and “In Defence of the Supreme Court: Rivers state Election judgment”(2017).
My Lord, if l defended the Supreme Court in the past by putting issues in proper perspective, beyond emotive vituperation, why wouldn’t l have the locus now to disagree, criticise or even upbraid it’s judgments in respect of the Senatorial seats of Yobe and Akwa Ibom as they relate to Ahmed Lawan and Godswill Akpabio?
As a matter of fact, C.C. Nweze, JSC, who read the lead judgment in the Lawan’s matter has been a long-time friend right from when he was on the High court Bench, Enugu. A cerebral, highly articulate, intellectually deep, incorruptible and uncompromising judicial officer for whom l have tremendous respect. I cannot, by any stretch of imagination denigrate him but l disagree with his judgment and l have the right to do disagree and make public. So, why should l be gagged for disagreeing with the majority judgment? Interestingly, the same highly respected Nweze, JSC, in his lone dissenting judgment in respect of the controversial Imo Governorship judgment of 2020, had stated in his dissent, that the majority judgment “will continue to haunt our electoral jurisprudence for a long time”. This presupposes that the court’s judgment would have to pass through the litmus test of scholarly and public scrutiny. As a matter of fact, in my analysis of the judgment, l described it as SUPREME INJUSTICE. In 2008, after the controversial Supreme Court judgment in respect of Amaechi v. Omehia, Gani Fawehinmi (of blessed memory), in his criticism of the judgment, he described it as “perverse”. Heavens didn’t fall. Till now, Nigerians are still debating the propriety of the 1979 twelve two-thirds judgment of the Supreme Court in the Awolowo v. Shagari election. Heavens have not fallen. So, why now?

My Lord, the Supreme Court has a lot to do to change the public perception about it because justice is rooted in public confidence and this cannot be achieved by threats and gagging members of the public from criticizing its judgments.
May l end this letter, my Lord, with these quotes:

“Judges and court alike are open to criticism and if reasonable argument or expostulation is offered against any judicial act as contrary to law or public good, no court could or would treat that as contempt of court”
-Lord Russel in Reg. v. Gray (1990) 2QB 40.

“Justice has no place in darkness and secrecy. When a judge sits on a case, he himself is on trial…If there is any misconduct on his part, any bias or prejudice, there is a reporter to keep an eye on him”.
-Lord Denning (Address before High court journalists Association, Dec.3, 1964).

“Justice is not a cloistered virtue. She must be allowed to suffer the scrutiny and respectful, even through outspoken comments of ordinary men”.
-Lord Atkin (Ambard v. AG of Trinidad and Tobago (1936) AC 322.

Having said that, with profound respect my Lord, l want to put you on notice that l would criticize the Supreme Court judgments if and when necessary.
My kind regards

RICHARD AKINNOLA
Publisher/Editor-in-Chief, COURTROOM;
Publisher/Editor-in-Chief, MEDIA LAW DIGEST;
Publisher, CORRUPTION CASES JOURNAL
Director, MEDIA LAW CENTRE
Director, LEGAL HISTORY CENTRE

VISIT OUR OTHER WEBSITES
PRNigeria.com EconomicConfidential.com PRNigeria.com/Hausa/
EmergencyDigest.com PoliticsDigest.ng TechDigest.ng
HealthDigest.ng SpokesPersonsdigest.com TeensDigest.ng
ArewaAgenda.com Hausa.ArewaAgenda.com YAShuaib.com
  • TAGS
  • Chief Justice of Nigeria
  • Law
  • Nigeria
Previous article2022 Elections: President Buhari Commissions Operational Vehicles, Crowd Control Equipments
Next articleBuhari Signs Business Facilitation Bill 2022 into Law
Richard Akinlola
Richard Akinlola

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Okello Oculi

Okello Oculi: A Pan-Africanist Asteroid Burns out Forever By Is’haq Modibbo Kawu

Department of State Security Service DSS

Army, DSS-Backed Hybrid Forces Neutralize 45 Bandits in Niger Operation

PRNigeria Young Communication Fellowship 2025 logo

PRNigeria Opens Application for 2025 Young Communication Fellowship

Troops of Operation FANSAN YANMA

Troops Kill Three Terrorist Leaders in Sokoto Ambush, Recover Weapons

Leon Usigbe

Death, you can’t be Proud of this By Abdulrahman Abdulraheem 

Bashir Adewale Adeniyi Customs Boss

How Customs is Tightening Borders to Stop Illicit Cash Flows – CG Adeniyi 

FACT-CHECK: Did a N10bn Lafia Flyover Collapse Three Weeks After Commissioning in Nasarawa?

Tinubu’s Plateau Gambit – Yilwatda, 2027, and the Return of the Machiavellian Strategist By Abdullahi O Haruna Haruspice

NAF combat-ready Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) operators

NAF Bolsters Battlespace Dominance with New Combat-Ready UAV Operators

PHOTOS: How Nigerian Military’s Coordinated Air and Ground Assault Crushed Terrorists in Warari Operation

Brigadier General Olakunle Oluseye Nafiu, Director General of the National Youth Service Corps (NYSC)

NYSC Seeks Stakeholder Support to Enhance Orientation Exercises

Late President Muhammadu Buhari

Walson-Jack: Buhari Was a Pillar of Integrity in Nigeria’s Public Sector

Recent Posts

  • Beyond Hoes and Sticks: The Power of Education for Peace in Arewa
  • Nigerian Air Force Welcomes 30 New Helicopter Pilots, Commissions Upgraded Facilities
  • FG Pledges Stronger Support for Blood Services, Seeks Scalable Interventions from NBSA
  • Tinubu’s Government Unveils Multi-Sectoral Initiatives to Boost Northern Region’s Development
  • FG Redesigns Agricultural Curriculum to Empower Youth
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
© 2020 PRNigeria. All Rights Reserved.
Latest News
Beyond Hoes and Sticks: The Power of Education for Peace in ArewaNigerian Air Force Welcomes 30 New Helicopter Pilots, Commissions Upgraded FacilitiesFG Pledges Stronger Support for Blood Services, Seeks Scalable Interventions from NBSATinubu's Government Unveils Multi-Sectoral Initiatives to Boost Northern Region's DevelopmentFG Redesigns Agricultural Curriculum to Empower YouthFG Secures China Funding to Fast-Track Kaduna–Kano Rail CompletionFG Unveils Livestock Blueprint to End Herdsmen-Farmers CrisisFG Completes 135 Roads, Launches 216 New Projects in Northern NigeriaJUST IN: Tinubu Appoints Olumode Adeyemi New CG of Fire ServiceTroops Neutralise 6 Terrorists in Coordinated Operations Across Borno, Recover FirearmsPolice Nab Woman Linked to Murder of Pregnant Nurse, Mutilation in Anambra NIPR Slams Fake News Peddlers over Alleged Lafia Flyover CollapseTinubu Offers Automatic Jobs, Gifts N250k to 210 Ex-CorpersKaduna Governor Appoints Strategic Communicator, Ahmed Maiyaki as Information CommissionerCustoms Partners US Mission to Prevent Expanded Visa Ban
X whatsapp