• Home
  • Anti-Corruption
  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
  • National
    • Government
  • Security
  • Features
  • State
  • Event
    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Search
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
PRNIGERIA PRNigeria News
PRNIGERIA PRNIGERIA
  • Home
  • Anti-Corruption
    • Chinese nationals jailed in Lagos

      Court Jails Nine Chinese Nationals for Cybercrime in Lagos

      ASUU

      Tackle Corruption, Institutional Decay – ASUU Charges FG

      EFCC Arraigns Bauchi Accountant General Over N8bn Fraud as Court Sentences…

      PRNigeria logo fearured image

      EFCC Arraigns Ex-Convict, Other for Naira Abuse in Lagos

      EFCC Arrests 37 Suspected Internet Fraudsters in Ilorin

  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
    • Comptroller General Nigerian Customs Bashir Adewale

      Nigeria Customs, ICPC and the Audit of Conscience

      Customs Diplomacy: Nigeria, Saudi Arabia Ink Mutual Assistance Deal

      Comptroller General Nigerian Customs Bashir Adewale

      Nigeria, Belarus Forge Alliance to Combat Smuggling, Facilitate Trade

      President Bola Ahmed Tinubu and CG Customs, Bashir Adewale Adeniyi

      Tinubu Hails Customs Boss Wale Adeniyi on Historic Election as WCO…

      WTO Lauds Nigeria Customs for Embracing Global Trade Standards

  • National
    • Domestic Violence

      Marriage and the Silent Wounds Within Homes By Hafsat Ibrahim

      The Nigerian Army @162: A Testament to Sacrifice and National Unity…

      Nigerian Military Troops

      Nigeria, Niger Forces Neutralize Score of ISWAP Terrorists in Mallamfatori

      A Different Kind of War on Drugs By As-Sayyidul Arafat Abdulrazaq

      HAJJ Pilgrims pilgrimage NAHCON

      NAHCON Completes 2025 Hajj Return Operations 

    • Government
      • G7 Countries

        Iran Must Never Possess Nuclear Weapons – G7 Declare

        Nigerian Dignitaries, Business Leaders Attend Aminu Dantata’s Burial in Madinah Saudi…

        Dantata laid to rest at Medina Cemetery

        Legendary Business Mogul Aminu Dantata Laid to Rest in Madinah Cemetery

        Tinubu Seeks Visa Waivers, Scholarships as Nigeria Establishes Diplomatic Ties with…

        Malam Yusuf Abubakar Dingyadi

        Dingyadi, PDP Chair’s Vocal Spokesperson, Resigns

  • Security
    • Suspected Gunrunner

      Plateau: Troops Nab Suspected Gunrunner, Recover AK-47, Ammunition in Plateau

      Troops Neutralise Scores of Militias in Plateau

      Army providing free medical aid

      Nigerian Army Provides Free Medical Aid, Educational Support in Zamfara Community

      Police, Pharma Manufacturers Partner to Combat Substandard Drugs in Kano

      The Director of Defence Media Operations, Major-General Markus Kangye,

      Nigerian Military Has No Power to Grant Bandits’ Amnesty — DHQ

  • Features
    • Domestic Violence

      Marriage and the Silent Wounds Within Homes By Hafsat Ibrahim

      FutureMap Foundation Sparks Innovation with Design Thinking in Nigeria

      The Nigerian Army @162: A Testament to Sacrifice and National Unity…

      Comptroller General Nigerian Customs Bashir Adewale

      Nigeria Customs, ICPC and the Audit of Conscience

      A Different Kind of War on Drugs By As-Sayyidul Arafat Abdulrazaq

  • State
    • Suspected Gunrunner

      Plateau: Troops Nab Suspected Gunrunner, Recover AK-47, Ammunition in Plateau

      Troops Neutralise Scores of Militias in Plateau

      Army providing free medical aid

      Nigerian Army Provides Free Medical Aid, Educational Support in Zamfara Community

      Police, Pharma Manufacturers Partner to Combat Substandard Drugs in Kano

      FCT Police Raid Criminals’ Hideouts, Arrest 56 Suspects

  • Event
    • NELFUND

      NELFUND Warns Students Against Fake Loan Application Portal

      EFCC Witness: Yahaya Bello Had No Property Dealings With EFAB

      Hon. Rukayat Motunrayo Shittu (RMS), with PRNigeria Ladies in PR I'm Abuja

      Rukayat Shittu Set to Publish Inspirational Book “Cracking the Glass Ceiling”,…

      Chief Cornelius Olatunji Adebayo

      Former Kwara Governor, Chief Adebayo, Dies at 84

      Managing Editor of Image Merchants, Mr Abdulrahman Abdulraheem, PR Expert, Celestine Achi and the Editor-in-chief, Yushau Shuaib presenting the book to PRNigeria center

      PRNigeria Commends New Book on Artificial Intelligence in Public Relations

    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Home Features Pantami in the Eyes of the Law By Yunus Abdulsalam
  • Features

Pantami in the Eyes of the Law By Yunus Abdulsalam

By
Yunus Abdulsalam
-
May 12, 2021
Professor Ali Pantami
Professor Ali Pantami

Pantami in the Eyes of the Law
By Yunus Abdulsalam

The labyrinth of accusations and counter-accusations surrounding the uproar over the hitherto sympathetic gesture of  the Honourable Minister of Communication and Digital Economy, Dr Isa Pantami for Al-Qaeda is another classic example of how objectivity always become the sacrificial lamb in the alter of our inordinate sentiments.

One of the saddening features discernible from virtually every issue of national discourse is the recurring decimal to see reactions and commentaries being tailored along ethnic, religious, political or other primordial sentiments.  And honestly speaking, this Pantami furore is not an exception.

My focus here will be on the legal and moral implications of what  Pantami did or said about 20 years ago as a private citizen.

In a country notorious for public interest litigations against public office holders suspected to have committed even minor infractions of the law, such as the cases of Ibrahim Magu erstwhile EFCC Chairman, former Ministers  Adebayo Shittu & Kemi Adeosun and recently the immediate past IGP Abubakar Adamu, is it not surprising that we are yet to see any lawsuit seeking for declaration that Pantami is unfit to hold public office? Or is this just another case of some fringe elements with ulterior motives doing as much as they can to damage the integrity of the Honourable minister?

This writer is not unaware of the contention from some quarters that the call for Pantami’s resignation is premised on breach of some moral codes. However I am curious to know how morality becomes superior to the law. The unassailable truth is that legality takes precedent over morality that is why lawmakers often take the moral standard of the society into consideration before arriving at any law. In fact, law remains the best standard of determining the moral standard of any society.

For instance, despite the prevalence of same-sex relationship all over the world and the facts that Nigerians love imitating anything associated with foreigners, our law criminalized  such practice despite the oppositions by western countries. Thus, law is the substratum upon which an egalitarian society is built upon.

It would therefore be safe to conclude that unless what Pantami did was in breach of the law as at that material, then the call for him to resign based on the misplaced logic of him having breached an undefined moral code is not only misguided, ungrounded but mischievous.

It is pertinent to emphasize that the above should not be misconstrued as admission that  Pantami might have breached any moral code because he has not in any way. But I only made such comparison of law and moral code to establish the unsoundness and illogicality of the arguments of those calling on him to resign purely for alleged breach of a phantom moral code.

Read Also:

  • Plateau: Troops Nab Suspected Gunrunner, Recover AK-47, Ammunition in Plateau
  • Troops Neutralise Scores of Militias in Plateau
  • ‎FACT-CHECK: Are Nigerian Soldiers Protecting Cattle Instead of Citizens in Yelewata Benue State as Shown in a Viral Video?

Under our criminal jurisprudence, the intention to commit an offence technically referred to as mens rea which is very  essential  among other ingredients required for an accused person to be criminally liable, is much stronger than having a mere sympathy for the perpetrators of an offence.  It is inconceivable to see and I am yet to be told of any law in which sympathy is the required mens rea.

Besides, the existence of mens rea without the requisite actus rea, which in this case will be the taking part in the planning or execution of an act of terror,will be insufficient to convict an accused person. In other words both the guilty intention which is not present in this case of Pantami and the guilty act which no one has alleged against him must co-exist before Pantami could be deemed to have committed any offence. This position of the law has received judicial blessings in plethora of judicial authorities. See the cases of Abeke vs State (2007) 9 NWLR (PT. 1040) 411, Ibikunle vs State (2005) 1  NWLR (PT. 907) 387.

Assuming without conceding that the sympathetic gestures 20 years ago was an offence, then for the fact that  Pantami has purged himself of that  controversial statements and beliefs long before this public outcry to the extent that he had an open debate with the founder and former leader of Boko Haram, Muhammad Yusuf and which put his life under threat by the present leader of the group  Abubakar Shekau who declared  his blood ‘halal’ or ‘lawful’, the position of the law is that Pantami will be exonerated by Section 25 of the Criminal Code  pursuant to defence of mistaken belief in a state of affairs.

The import of that section is that where a person acts under a mistaken belief as to some state of fact he honestly believes to exist, and in the process an illegal act is committed, the defence of mistake will avail such a person. See Board of Customs & Excise v. Barau (1982) 10 SC 4. The point is that if the law can avail a person for an offence committed under a mistaken belief, how magnanimous would you think the law would be on Pantami who did not commit any offence at that material time but merely made a sympathetic gesture under a mistaken beliefs which he had divested himself from in a manner that has made him subject of target by deadly Boko Haram?

For once let us pretend to be objective as the law. Can one call Sheikh Gumi a bandit because he believed the bandits terrorizing some communities could have some justifications for their nefarious activities? Rev, Fr Mbaka recently called Nnamdi kanu, a wanted fugitive his anointed son; will that be sufficient to link him to the series of crimes and atrocities alleged committed by kanu and his group IPOB ? Let not forget that IPOB has already designated a terrorist organisation under the Nigerian law but the group  has been receiving tacit support from eminent personalities from their region of extraction, yet no one is calling for the heads of those sympathizers.

Pantami is another victim of how our toxic perspective to national issues strays public discourse into our artificial fault lines. The Honourable Minister should however be consoled by his unprecedented and incontrovertible giant strides in his ministry and the exculpatory position of our law in his favour.

Abdulsalam, a legal practitioner writes from Abuja

VISIT OUR OTHER WEBSITES
PRNigeria.com EconomicConfidential.com PRNigeria.com/Hausa/
EmergencyDigest.com PoliticsDigest.ng TechDigest.ng
HealthDigest.ng SpokesPersonsdigest.com TeensDigest.ng
ArewaAgenda.com Hausa.ArewaAgenda.com YAShuaib.com
  • TAGS
  • buhari
  • Digital Economy
  • Pantami
  • Terrorism
Previous articleDefence Minister Seeks Spiritual Weapons to Defeat Adversaries
Next articleUnknown Gunmen: Security Forces Nab Awurum Eze, another Most Wanted IPOB Leader in South-East
Yunus Abdulsalam
Yunus Abdulsalam
Xing

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Domestic Violence

Marriage and the Silent Wounds Within Homes By Hafsat Ibrahim

FutureMap Foundation Sparks Innovation with Design Thinking in Nigeria

The Nigerian Army @162: A Testament to Sacrifice and National Unity By Sani Kukasheka Usman

Comptroller General Nigerian Customs Bashir Adewale

Nigeria Customs, ICPC and the Audit of Conscience

A Different Kind of War on Drugs By As-Sayyidul Arafat Abdulrazaq

For Aminu Dantata to Sleep Well… By Abdullahi O Haruna Haruspice

Bashir Adewale Adeniyi Customs Boss

Bashir Adeniyi: A Roadmap to Global Customs Leadership By Tahir Ahmad

IGP Kayode Egbetokun Police Boss

IGP Egbetokun: Leading the Charge for a Safer Nigeria By Danjuma S. Musa

NDLEA Logo

Drug Culture in Nigerian Music: When Art Imitates Harm By Arafat A. Abdulrazaq

Ambassador Yusuf Maitama Tuggar

Ambassador Tuggar’s Doctrine of Calm in a World on Fire By Umar Farouk Bala

A brief travelogue by Fredrick Nwabufo

WTO Lauds Nigeria Customs for Embracing Global Trade Standards

Recent Posts

  • Plateau: Troops Nab Suspected Gunrunner, Recover AK-47, Ammunition in Plateau
  • Troops Neutralise Scores of Militias in Plateau
  • ‎FACT-CHECK: Are Nigerian Soldiers Protecting Cattle Instead of Citizens in Yelewata Benue State as Shown in a Viral Video?
  • Nigerian Army Provides Free Medical Aid, Educational Support in Zamfara Community
  • Marriage and the Silent Wounds Within Homes By Hafsat Ibrahim
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
© 2020 PRNigeria. All Rights Reserved.
Latest News
Plateau: Troops Nab Suspected Gunrunner, Recover AK-47, Ammunition in PlateauTroops Neutralise Scores of Militias in Plateau‎FACT-CHECK: Are Nigerian Soldiers Protecting Cattle Instead of Citizens in Yelewata Benue State as Shown in a Viral Video?Nigerian Army Provides Free Medical Aid, Educational Support in Zamfara CommunityMarriage and the Silent Wounds Within Homes By Hafsat IbrahimPolice, Pharma Manufacturers Partner to Combat Substandard Drugs in KanoFutureMap Foundation Sparks Innovation with Design Thinking in NigeriaNigerian Military Has No Power to Grant Bandits' Amnesty — DHQHow a Single Electricity Market Will Empower Africa’s People and EconomiesThe Nigerian Army @162: A Testament to Sacrifice and National Unity By Sani Kukasheka UsmanWorld’s Largest Electricity Market Kicks Off as AU Launches Steering Committee to Drive Continental IntegrationMilitary Kills Terrorist Commanders, Arrests Over 1,100 Others in Q2 Operations – DHQFCT Police Raid Criminals' Hideouts, Arrest 56 SuspectsNigeria, Niger Forces Neutralize Score of ISWAP Terrorists in MallamfatoriNigeria Customs, ICPC and the Audit of Conscience
X whatsapp