• Home
  • Anti-Corruption
  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
  • National
    • Government
  • Security
  • Features
  • State
  • Event
    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Search
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
PRNIGERIA PRNigeria News
PRNIGERIA PRNIGERIA
  • Home
  • Anti-Corruption
    • ICPC Secures Conviction of Rector for Running Unaccredited Degree Programmes

      Engr Abba Babagana Dalori

      Engr Dalori Forfeits Galaxy Hospital, Petrol Station, Properties & Cash

      Chinese nationals jailed in Lagos

      Court Jails Nine Chinese Nationals for Cybercrime in Lagos

      ASUU

      Tackle Corruption, Institutional Decay – ASUU Charges FG

      EFCC Arraigns Bauchi Accountant General Over N8bn Fraud as Court Sentences…

  • Fact-Check
  • Economy
    • Luanda Summit: AUDA-NEPAD Taps AI, Green Bonds as it Launches Marketplace…

      Tinubu Jets to Brazil After Japan Summit, Eyes Trade, Security Deals

      Comptroller-General of Customs, Bashir Adewale Adeniyi (MFR), hosted the Executive Chairman of FIRS, Dr. Zacch Adedeji,

      Customs and the “National Single Window” Project

      FG Earmarks N13bn to Boost Power Infrastructure in Lagos, Ogun

      Centre for Crisis Communication, CCC,

      CCC Reviews Keyamo’s Crisis Management in Aviation Disputes

  • National
    • Flood

      Flood Alert: Heavy Rains Threaten 7 Nigerian States this Weekend August…

      Officers of NCS as it rounds off its Strategic Reputation Management Campaign in Zone 'D', Bauchi

      Customs Consolidates Reforms as Reputation Campaign Wraps Up in Zone ‘D’

      CG Custom Bashir Adewale Adeniyi and Zacch Adedeji

      Is Zacch Adedeji Building Bridges for Nigeria’s Revenue Future? By Yushau…

      Army soldiers security

      Mattress of Terror: Can Nigeria Ever Be Truly Secure? By Haroon…

      ACF

      Arewa Consultative Forum Engages Influencers to Amplify Northern Identity

    • Government
      • CG Custom Bashir Adewale Adeniyi and Zacch Adedeji

        Is Zacch Adedeji Building Bridges for Nigeria’s Revenue Future? By Yushau…

        ACF

        Arewa Consultative Forum Engages Influencers to Amplify Northern Identity

        FG, States, LGs Share N2.001trn for July, Says FAAC

        FG Unveils Personal Income Tax Calculator Under New Reform Laws

        Saudi Arabia Conducts Life-Saving Cardiac surgeries in Kano

        Saudi Arabia Conducts Life-Saving Cardiac Surgeries in Kano

  • Security
    • Police Neutralise Kidnappers, Arrest Suspects, Recover Arms in Nationwide Crackdown

      Police Officer

      Police Raid Bandits’ Camps, Recover Arms, Arrest Suspects in Benue

      Flood

      Flood Alert: Heavy Rains Threaten 7 Nigerian States this Weekend August…

      NAF Eliminates Over 35 Terrorists at Assembly Point Near Cameroon Border

      Police Arrest 65-Year-Old Arms Trader, Suspected Chinese Illegal Miner in Anambra

  • Features
    • CG Custom Bashir Adewale Adeniyi and Zacch Adedeji

      Is Zacch Adedeji Building Bridges for Nigeria’s Revenue Future? By Yushau…

      Army soldiers security

      Mattress of Terror: Can Nigeria Ever Be Truly Secure? By Haroon…

      The Arrest of Ansaru Kingpins Mahmud Muhammad Usman aka Abu Bara’a, and Mahmud al-Nigeri aka Mallam Mamuda

      Ribadu and the fall of Ansaru By Senator Iroegbu

      Fixing the Fault Lines in Nigeria’s Culture of Recognition, By Mukhtar…

      How Desperation Turns Nigerian Job Seekers Into Scam Targets By Tahir…

  • State
    • Police Neutralise Kidnappers, Arrest Suspects, Recover Arms in Nationwide Crackdown

      Police Officer

      Police Raid Bandits’ Camps, Recover Arms, Arrest Suspects in Benue

      Nigerian Navy Personnel

      Navy Dismantles Illegal Refining Site in Bayelsa

      ACF

      Arewa Consultative Forum Engages Influencers to Amplify Northern Identity

      CRUSHING BLOW: other Top Boko Haram commanders neutralized in Bita, Wigo

  • Event
    • President Bola Ahmed Tinubu

      His Death is a National Loss, Tinubu Mourns Emir of Zuru

      Umar Lauya

      Umar Lauya Declares Candidacy for NYCN Presidency, Vows to Unite and…

      The Executive Secretary/CEO of the National Sugar Department Council (NSDC), Mr. Kamar Bakrin (L), with the CEO of Legacy Sugar Company, Alh. Abubakar Isa Musa (R), during the signing ceremony.

      NSDC, New Operators Seal Landmark Development Agreements, to Produce 400,000MT of…

      Regional Vice President Western and Central Africa at the World Bank, Mr Ousmane Diagana pays a courtesy visit to Baze University

      World Bank Vice President visits Baze University, Commends Educational Standards, Assures…

      NIPR President Ike Neliaku and a recently inducted PR professional from Kano

      PHOTOS: NIPR Inducts 80 New PR Professionals in Kano to its…

    • PR Nigeria Award
  • E-Paper
Home Fact-Check Fact Check: Did President Tinubu Approve ‘’Doctrine of Necessity’ for the Removal...
  • Fact-Check

Fact Check: Did President Tinubu Approve ‘’Doctrine of Necessity’ for the Removal of Gov Akeredolu of Ondo?

By
Prnigeria
-
November 27, 2023
Governor Akeredolu and his deputy Lucky Aiyedatiwa

Fact Check: Did President Tinubu Approve ‘’Doctrine of Necessity’ for the Removal of Gov Akeredolu of Ondo?

Claims: The online media is suddenly agog with the news that President Bola Ahmed Tinubu approved the removal of the recuperating governor of Ondo State, Rotimi Akeredolu over his inability to continue as governor of the state due to his controversial state of health.

Full Text: According to the report by an online media platform the president approved the removal of Akeredolu by invoking the “doctrine of necessity.” 

The story was captioned as follows “Tinubu Approves Akeredolu’s Removal, Declaration of Deputy as Ondo Acting Governor”, and had the following text which read in part, “President Tinubu, along with other All Progressives Congress (APC) leaders, has agreed to invoke the doctrine of necessity to appoint embattled Deputy Governor Lucky Aiyedatiwa as acting governor, effectively resolving the five-month-long crisis in the state. The decision was reached during a closed-door meeting held at the Presidential Villa in Abuja on Friday.”

The news report followed by reactions from the online community. A certain user who identifies as Great Abdul reads, “person no feel fine. e still wan they govern from sick bed.why are our Leaders very selfish.”

Another user Adebisi Gbenga said, “Our president tap from Solomon wisdom,may God protect him always in Jesus name,” while another user Augustus Ogbuka said “l am not a fan of Tinubu but that is the right thing to do.”

The story had at the time 384 top comments on the online news platform.

Background

The recent crisis in Ondo State arose from governor Rotimi Akeredolu’s prolonged recuperation leading to a public outcry and call for his immediate resignation. Notable among those calling for his resignation a former Presidential candidate and acclaimed activist, Omoyele Sowore, who is also the publisher of Sahara Reporters. The State Chapter of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), equally questioned the governor’s resolve to remain at his private residence in Ibadan after his return from overseas for treatment.

Recall that governor Akeredolu, early June this year went on a 21-day medical leave abroad for treatment after a protracted ailment.

Upon his return, the governor is yet to set foot in Akure, the state capital, instead, he is staying at his personal residence in Ibadan.

The governor returned to the country in September, 2023, after almost 4 months in Germany for treatment for an undisclosed ailment. He had since his return been carrying out his official duties from his homein Ibadan, Oyo State. The situation has displeased many, particularly from the opposition camp as they doubt his ability to lead the State in full capacity.

While the First Lady, Betty Anyanwu-Akeredolu, has been accused of pulling the strings on state functions, Akeredolu and his deputy, Aiyedatiwa have been at loggerhead over the forthcoming 2024 governorship election in the state.

Verification: While the media had different versions of the reports including  “Tinubu Approves Akeredolu’s Removal, Paves Way For Aiyedatiwa As Ondo Acting…” and “JUST-IN: Tinubu Wades Into Akeredolu, Aiyedatiwa Feud As Lawmakers Shun Ondo Assembly,” a report in the Guardian that “Tinubu, stakeholders agree on doctrine of necessity to oust Akeredolu..” creates more curiosities.

According to the report in the Guardian, “the five-month political impasse in Ondo State over the absence of Governor Rotimi Akeredolu SAN, may soon come to an end as President Bola Ahmed Tinubu and other critical stakeholders in the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC), yesterday, agreed to invoke the principle of necessity to proclaim the embattled deputy governor, Lucky Aiyedatiwa as acting governor of the state. The President yesterday met with some Akeredolu’s cabinet members and Ondo State lawmakers at the Presidential Villa, Abuja, where they took the decision…”

Doctrine of Necessity

The doctrine of necessity according to Wikipedia “is the basis on which extraordinary actions by administrative authority, which are designed to restore order or uphold fundamental constitutional principles, are considered to be lawful even if such an action contravenes established laws….”

This principle of “doctrine of necessity” was was first applied on 10 January, 2010 when the former Senate President, David Mark was visited by concern Nigerians to wade into the situation of the state of health of the late president Umoru Yar’Adua and his capabilities to continue as president of Nigeria while he was away on medical treatment abroad, the matter that almost rocked the foundation of this country. 

Read Also:

  • Police Neutralise Kidnappers, Arrest Suspects, Recover Arms in Nationwide Crackdown
  • Police Raid Bandits’ Camps, Recover Arms, Arrest Suspects in Benue
  • Arewa Economic Forum Chairman Loses Mother

The former Senate President, with the federal lawmakers consulted the former Chief justice of the Federation, S.B.Belgore on the legality of making ex-president Jonathan, who was the vice president at the time, as acting president. Justice Belgore said “the constitution recognized the doctrine of necessity”, which he advised the Senate to apply to salvage the situation at hand; even though justice Abutu’s rulings expressly stated that the principle could not solve the problem.

However, it was not a sitting president that applied this emergency doctrine, it was the lawmakers and this didn’t apply to the state at the time.

Nonetheless, governor Akeredolu, according to report, was the President of the Nigerian Bar Association during the sickness of Umar Musa Yar’Adua, and was very vocal in the call for the resignation of the then-president over his health.

“No matter how much you love your country, it should not be at the detriment of your health. It is not your party or your wife that will decide whether you are capable of handling state matters; it is only your doctors that can decide that. The bar is not asking the president not to come back and take his seat, but the right thing must be done,” Akeredolu had said in 2010.

Does the President have the Power to Remove a Governor?

But the question remains, does the president have the power to remove the governor of a state?

Interestingly, besides the application of the doctrine of necessity which the constitution recognizes and permits, if the need arises. 

The only constitutional means in which a sitting governor can be removed from office is, according to legal experts, in the case of health challenges, “the first move to remove the governor must start from the commissioners, who have the power to declare that the governor is incapacitated.”

Rasheed Bakare, a legal practitioner in Abuja, explained that Section 189 of the 1999 constitution provides the steps to be taken before a governor or deputy governor can be declared incapacitated to continue in that office.

According to section 189 of the Nigerian Constitution, only the commissioners of Ondo State can trigger the process of declaring Mr Akeredolu incapacitated.

 

The first step is that 2/3 of the state executive council must resolve that the Governor is incapacitated to continue in office.

 

  1. (1) The Governor or Deputy Governor of a State shall cease to hold office if, by a resolution passed by a two-thirds majority of all members of the executive council of the State, it is declared that the Governor or Deputy Governor is incapable of discharging the functions of his office,” the constitution reads in part.

After the resolution by the body of commissioners, the constitution provides that the speaker must set up a panel to examine the health status of the governor.

The medical panel must comprise five medical practitioners, including the physician of the governor. The panel must determine that the “Governor or Deputy Governor is suffering from such infirmity of body or mind as renders him permanently incapable of discharging the functions of his office, a notice thereof signed by the Speaker of the House of Assembly shall be published in the Official.”

These constitutional provisions didn’t give the president the power to remove a state governor under any circumstances.

Nevertheless, contrary to the widely circulated claims by some media platforms, a press statement released during the week by the Special Adviser to the President⁣, Media and Publicity, Chief Ajuri Ngelale⁣, clarified that President Tinubu only “advised all opposing parties to bury the hatchet and embrace peace, eliciting commitments to this effect.”

It further emphasised that, “this means that Governor Akeredolu remains Chief Executive of the State, Aiyedatiwa remains Deputy Governor, and members of the State Executive Council continue their respective duties, even as the leadership of the State’s House of Assembly and the APC Chapter in Ondo State is preserved.⁣..”

The Deputy Governor also pledged to maintain status quo, embarce everyone and also put behind all that has happened as advised by President Tinubu. 

As calls to declare Mr Akeredolu incapacitated, 33 out of the 35 State Executive Council members passed a vote of confidence on the ailing governor and declared their loyalty to him.

Only the Commissioner for Energy and Mineral Resources, Razak Obe, and the Commissioner for Commerce, Industry, and Cooperative Services, Akin Sowore did not sign the document.

Conclusion: findings by PRNigeria fact-check reveal as follows: 

Besides the “doctrine of necessity” which is rarely invoked, the president doesn’t not have the constitutional powers to remove the governor of a state.

The removal of a state governor is the exclusive power of the state house of assembly based on the dictates of the constitution and the circumstances.

Also, president Tinubu’s intervention – which is based on part affiliation – was to reconcile warring parties in the ongoing crisis in Ondo State. 

The doctrine of necessity was not even part of the discussion with the President. 

33 out of the 35 State Executive Council members passed a vote of confidence on the ailing governor and declared their loyalty to him.

PRNigeria therefore concludes that the reports that President Tinubu approved the removal of the recuperating governor of Ondo State, Rotimi Akeredolu over his inability to continue as governor of the state due to his state of health is Misleading.

By PRNigeria 

VISIT OUR OTHER WEBSITES
PRNigeria.com EconomicConfidential.com PRNigeria.com/Hausa/
EmergencyDigest.com PoliticsDigest.ng TechDigest.ng
HealthDigest.ng SpokesPersonsdigest.com TeensDigest.ng
ArewaAgenda.com Hausa.ArewaAgenda.com YAShuaib.com
  • TAGS
  • Ahmed Bola Tinubu
  • Governor Akeredolu
  • Ondo State
Previous articleREPORTER’s DIARY: Reminiscing my Encounter with HPV Vaccine in the Era of Misinformation
Next articleHealth Ministry Reacts to Unrest at OAUTH Ife
Prnigeria
Prnigeria

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Ibrahim Yahaya Dandakata of Arewa Economic Forum

Arewa Economic Forum Chairman Loses Mother

Flood

Flood Alert: Heavy Rains Threaten 7 Nigerian States this Weekend August 24-24

Police Recover arms from Boko Haram in Borno

Man, 65, arrested for illegal arms deal in Anambra – Police

Delegations Arrive Abuja for Inaugural African Defence Chiefs Summit

Troops of Operation FANSAN YANMA

Troops Neutralise 7 Bandits, Recover Motorcycles in Katsina

CRUSHING BLOW: other Top Boko Haram commanders neutralized in Bita, Wigo

Rotimi Pedro, Karimah Bello, Stella Din Jacob, Sophia Essahmed

PHOTOS: Finally, President Tinubu Confirms Pedro as NTA DG, Announces Three Female Executive Directors

Nigerian Military Refutes Misinterpretation of CDS Self-Defence Comment

Anambra Police Nab Suspected Vandals, Recover Transformer Parts, High-Tension Cables

Tinubu Jets to Brazil After Japan Summit, Eyes Trade, Security Deals

Saudi Arabia Conducts Life-Saving Cardiac surgeries in Kano

Saudi Arabia Conducts Life-Saving Cardiac Surgeries in Kano

Chief of Defence Staff (CDS), Gen. Christopher Musa

CDS Musa Charges Citizens to Learn Combat Skills for Self-Defence

Recent Posts

  • Police Neutralise Kidnappers, Arrest Suspects, Recover Arms in Nationwide Crackdown
  • Police Raid Bandits’ Camps, Recover Arms, Arrest Suspects in Benue
  • Arewa Economic Forum Chairman Loses Mother
  • Luanda Summit: AUDA-NEPAD Taps AI, Green Bonds as it Launches Marketplace for Africa’s Infrastructure Push
  • Flood Alert: Heavy Rains Threaten 7 Nigerian States this Weekend August 24-24
  • Home
  • About
  • Adverts
  • Contact
© 2020 PRNigeria. All Rights Reserved.
Latest News
Police Neutralise Kidnappers, Arrest Suspects, Recover Arms in Nationwide CrackdownPolice Raid Bandits’ Camps, Recover Arms, Arrest Suspects in BenueArewa Economic Forum Chairman Loses MotherLuanda Summit: AUDA-NEPAD Taps AI, Green Bonds as it Launches Marketplace for Africa’s Infrastructure PushFlood Alert: Heavy Rains Threaten 7 Nigerian States this Weekend August 24-24NAF Eliminates Over 35 Terrorists at Assembly Point Near Cameroon BorderPolice Arrest 65-Year-Old Arms Trader, Suspected Chinese Illegal Miner in AnambraCustoms Consolidates Reforms as Reputation Campaign Wraps Up in Zone ‘D’Navy Dismantles Illegal Refining Site in BayelsaIs Zacch Adedeji Building Bridges for Nigeria’s Revenue Future? By Yushau A. ShuaibMattress of Terror: Can Nigeria Ever Be Truly Secure? By Haroon Aremu AbiodunArewa Consultative Forum Engages Influencers to Amplify Northern IdentityMan, 65, arrested for illegal arms deal in Anambra - PoliceDelegations Arrive Abuja for Inaugural African Defence Chiefs SummitTroops Neutralise 7 Bandits, Recover Motorcycles in Katsina
X whatsapp