Bincike: Wanene Aka Nuna a cikin ‘Hoton’ 1937 na Sarakunan Arewa, Sarauniya Elizabeth ko Gimbiya Margaret?

Bincike: Wanene Aka Nuna a cikin ‘Hoton’ 1937 na Sarakunan Arewa, Sarauniya Elizabeth ko Gimbiya Margaret?

Da’awar : Hoton Sultan Hassan Dan Muazu da Sarkin Gwandu Shehu mai shekaru “1937” tare da wata budurwa ‘yar Burtaniya a Ingila ya ce karamar Sarauniya Elizabeth ce yayin da wasu ke jayayya cewa marigayiya Gimbiya Margaret.

Dubawa:

Wani rubutu da aka wallafa a Facebook kwanan nan tare da hoton yana cewa, “Dangantaka tsakanin cibiyoyin gargajiya na Najeriya da Masarautar Burtaniya ta yi nisa… Ga wasu shugabannin Arewa guda biyu tare da wata yarinya da aka bayyana a rubuce-rubuce da yawa a matsayin Gimbiya Elizabeth a 1937.”

Da yake yin karin haske a wata tsokaci, Mawallafin Daily Nigerian, Jaafar Jaafar, ya lura cewa Sultan Hassan dan Muazu, Sarkin Gwandu Usuman dan Halliru da Sarkin Kano Abdullahi Bayero sun ziyarci Landan sau daya a watan Yuni 1934 ba 1937 ba kamar yadda aka nuna a hoton da ke nuna.

“Na biyu, yarinyar da ke zaune a tsakaninsu ba Sarauniya Elizabeth ba ce. Idan ka kwatanta hotuna daban-daban na yarinyar gimbiya a 1934, za ka gane cewa babu kama da yarinyar da aka kwatanta a nan. Elizabeth tana da salon gyara gashi na musamman da ta kiyaye tun kuruciya.

“Hakika jam’iyyar (daya bayan daya) ta sami ‘yan kallo tare da Sarki George V (kakan Sarauniya Elizabeth) a ranar 2 ga Yuli, 1934, amma ina shakka ko an bar ‘ya’yan sarauta su hadu da baki. Haka kuma wasu manyan hafsoshin mulkin mallaka da ‘yan kasuwa da suka yi ritaya sun shirya wa sarakunan liyafa a gidajensu.

Na yi imani cewa las din na iya zama wata yarinya da aka sadu da ita ko dai a lokacin yawon bude ido, ko a gidan daya daga cikin tsoffin jami’an mulkin mallaka. Sanannen daga cikin tsoffin jami’an ‘yan mulkin mallaka da suka ziyarta akwai Lord Lugard a Arbinger.

Wani mai sharhin Sahabo Njidda, ya ce:

“Bugu da ƙari, an haifi Sarauniya Elizabeth a ranar 21 ga Afrilu 1926. Zuwa 1937, za ta cika shekara 11 da haihuwa. Yarinyar da aka nuna a hoton ba ta kai wannan shekarun ba. Ita ma ba ta kai 8yrs ba, idan za mu ɗauka cewa an ɗauki hoton a 1934.

Game da Sarauniya Elizabeth II:

Elizabeth II, cikakkiyar Elizabeth Alexandra Mary, (an haife ta 21 ga Afrilu, 1926, London, Eng. — ta mutu Satumba 8, 2022, Balmoral Castle, Aberdeenshire, Scot.), Sarauniyar Burtaniya daga 1952 zuwa 2022. Ta zama magaji zato lokacin da kawunta, Edward VIII, ya yi murabus kuma mahaifinta ya zama sarki a matsayin George VI

Game da Gimbiya Margaret:

Gimbiya Margaret Rose Windsor (1930 – 2002), Countess of Snowdon kuma kanwar Sarauniya Elizabeth II, ta kasance ɗaya daga cikin shahararrun dangin sarauta a tarihin zamani. An santa da halinta na tawaye da ƙayyadaddun halayenta, ta yi kanun labarai a duniya don salon rayuwarta na ‘ party-yarinya’ da dangantakarta da Kyaftin Rukunin equerry na mahaifinta Peter Townsend – soyayyar da ta fito a cikin jerin abubuwan ban mamaki na Netflix The Crown.

Tabbatarwa:

Don bincika da’awar PRNigeria ta yi ƙoƙarin cire fayil ɗin Exif hoton amma sakamakon ya dawo kamar “ba a sami metadata na Exif don hoton ba.”

PRNigeria , don haka, ta gudanar da binciken hoto na baya na hoton kuma sakamakon ya nuna cewa yawancin wallafe-wallafen sun bayyana budurwar a cikin hoton a matsayin “Sarauniya Elizabeth II,” duk da haka, wannan ya kasance bayan sanannen matsayi na farko da ke hade da hoton a kan layi ta hanyar Pinterest in 2014 da kuma a 2015 na Aminu Gamawa, wanda ya yi digiri na biyu da kuma Ph.D. Lauyan lauya daga Harvard Law School a Jami’ar Harvard, Amurka.

Sai dai jim kadan bayan mukaminsa , Gamawa wanda ya kasance kwamishinan kasafin kudi kuma a halin yanzu

Shugaban ma’aikatan gwamnan jihar Bauchi ta fayyace cewa matar da ke cikin hoton da alama Gimbiya Margaret ne, ba Elizabeth ba.

“Gyara: Yarinyar da ke cikin hoton Sultan Hassan na 1937 mai yiwuwa ita ce Marigayi Gimbiya Margaret, ba Sarauniya Elizabeth ba.”PRNigeria ya yi ƙoƙari da yawa don samunsa don fayyace madogararsa amma duk ya ci tura saboda layinsa ba ya haɗi.

Ko da yake binciken da aka yi ya nuna cewa ya bayar da wani dogon “ gyara ” a shafinsa na Facebook.

A cewarsa, “Ina so in yi wani muhimmin gyara game da bayanin wannan hoton. Wani mai ilimi sosai yayi kyakkyawan kallo akan yiwuwar kuskure a cikin bayanin hoton. Anan, a ƙasa, shine abin da ya rubuta: ‘Amma (curator’s ko edita’s) taken hoto ba daidai ba ne kuma yaudara.

Idan da gaske hoto ne na matashiyar Elizabeth, Sarauniyar Ingila ta yanzu, taken bai kamata ya bayyana ta a matsayin “Sarauniya Elizabeth ta biyu ba”, kamar yadda ake yi, tunda ba ita ce sarauniya ba lokacin da aka ɗauki hoton. Ita ce Gimbiya Elizabeth. Taken ya kamata ya bayyana ta kamar haka, watakila tare da ƙari na “… Sarauniya Elizabeth ta biyu ta yanzu.

“Wani matsala da nake da ita game da hoton ita ce ganin hotunan da aka yi a baya na matashiya Elizabeth (“Lillybet” ga kawunta marigayi, Lord Mountbatten), da yawa tare da kanwarta marigayi Gimbiya Margaret, a ra’ayi na, wannan da aka ce bai yi ba. sun yi kama da Sarauniya a lokacin ƙuruciyarta, kamar yadda sauran hotunan suke yi. Saboda haka, yana iya zama da kyau a tantance shi.’“Na yarda da abin da ya lura. Zan buga, a ƙasa, wani hoto na 1937 na Gimbiya Elizabeth don kwatanta.

PRNigeria , don haka, idan aka kwatanta 1937 daban-daban da kuma sauran hotuna masu girma na lokacin Gimbiya Elizabeth da Gimbiya Margaret kuma an tabbatar da cewa yayin da yarinyar da ke cikin hoton za a iya cewa ta yi kama da karamar gimbiya Margaret, ba ta da kama da Elizabeth. 1937.

An kara tabbatar da ita ta hanyar kwatancen cewa hakika “Lillbeth” kamar yadda iyayenta suka kira marigayi Sarauniya Elizabeth sun kiyaye salon gyara gashi wanda ke da curls na halitta kuma yana da sha’awar musamman ga magoya bayan sarauta.

Hoton 1937 na Lillibeth yana nuna irin salon gyara gashi wanda a matsayin yarinya Gimbiya , Elizabeth ta sa gashin kanta kuma yana kusa da tsawon kafada. Godiya ga masu gyaran gashi, Sarauniyar ta kiyaye tsarin da aka tsara tsawon shekaru.

Babban canjin da ya yi fice kamar yadda aka ruwaito shi ne cewa ta daina rini kuma ta sanya shi iri-iri.

Mai gyaran gashi na Sarauniya na kusan shekaru 20, Ian Carmichael da mai ba da shawara na dogon lokaci , Angela Kelly sun kasance masu aminci kuma ba su taɓa yin magana a bainar jama’a game da yanke gashin Sarauniya ba.Koyaya, ‘yar jarida Dame Esther Rantzen kwanan nan ta ba da haske game da yadda mai martaba ke son gashinta.

“Na sadu da wani, wanda shi ne mai gyaran gashi na Sarauniya, wanda ya ce abin da ta ke so kuma ta nace shi ne cewa gashinta yana da kama da juna,” in ji mai watsa labarai Dame Esther Rantzen.

Ta ci gaba da cewa: “Dole gashin kanta ya zama iri ɗaya daga wannan profile sannan zuwa wancan, ta yadda duk wani bangare da mutane ke kallonta, gashinta koyaushe yana kama da daidai.”

Kammalawa: yayin da babu wata takarda mai izini na jama’a da za ta tabbatar da ko Gimbiya Elizabeth ce ko Margaret a cikin hoton 1937 tare da sarakunan gargajiya biyu na Arewa a Ingila, isasshen ilimin ya nuna cewa ba zai yiwu ya zama marigayi Sarauniya Elizabeth ta biyu ba matashi.